Companies and individuals who enforce private carparks should be registered and controlled in a similar manner to security guards, says the car review website dogandlemon.com.
Motoring expert Clive Matthew-Wilson says parking enforcement companies often operate at the edge of the law and virtually without government supervision.
“With the government’s help, these parking companies are effectively the judge, jury and executioner. They use automated number plate recognition systems, accessing government computers to hand out bogus ‘tickets’, often to innocent people.”
“Many of these ‘tickets’ have the look and feel of an official government or council parking infringement. But unlike the government, private companies cannot legally impose fines because they are not a legal authority. So private parking enforcement companies rely on penalty clauses hidden in terms and conditions on a sign displayed somewhere in the carpark. These parking companies then claim they have a contract with the person who parked.”
“Often, the signs warning of these parking penalties are poorly displayed and would effectively require the motorist to walk over, read and understand the terms and conditions displayed on this sign before entering the carpark. Often, the motorist is simply unaware of any parking restrictions until a bogus ‘ticket’ arrives.”
“As part of this scam, many parking enforcement companies offer a largely bogus dispute mechanism that is designed to have the look and feel of something official. It is not. It’s doubtful that anyone is ever willingly let off one of these bogus ‘tickets’.”
An Auckland man told the NZ Herald he was lucky he had a dashcam after being ‘ticketed’ by Parking Services Limited in East Tāmaki.
The company claimed he’d used a gym carpark and hit him with a $95 ticket, saying it had to be paid within 21 days or incur an additional $75 per week in late payment fees.
The man showed his own dashcam footage to Parking Services Limited, which simply ignored his protests. It was only after the Herald became involved that Parking Services accepted the man hadn’t used one of the spaces it monitored and dropped the charges.
Matthew-Wilson believes the government should rigorously control parking enforcement companies.
“First, I’d like the law changed so that enforcement companies cannot simply display a sign somewhere and then fine users of a carpark. These companies should have to clearly and unambiguously inform carpark users of any parking terms and conditions. Most current carparks would not pass this test. The sign with the terms and conditions of use is often simply displayed in a manner that the average motorist would easily miss and/or fail to understand.”
"Second, the government should stop supplying these companies with cheap and easy access to motorists’ private data.”
Over the last decade, Australian states Queensland, New South Wales and Victoria have all stopped the sale of motorists’ data to private enforcement companies, to stop private operators from issuing intimidating payment notices that mimic government fines. [1, 2, 3]
“Third, it's time New Zealand parking enforcement companies were registered and controlled.”
“Security guards have to be registered and can lose their registrations and be fined heavily for illegal or reckless conduct. Yet New Zealand parking enforcement companies lack effective government oversight. Worse, the government helps these scammers by providing low cost access to motorists' private data on government computers.”
“Parking enforcement companies and their agents should be required to have both registration and proof of good character. Scammers should have their registrations cancelled and be criminally prosecuted.”
“There are already effective systems in place for parking enforcement, including towing away cars that are illegally parked. But the current New Zealand system is hopelessly rigged in favour of property owners, at the expense of ordinary motorists.”